Normaalisti Pathfinder Societyssa voi pelata kunkin seikkailun vain kerran pelaajana ja kerran pelinvetäjänä. Societyssä on kuitenkin myös tiettyjä skenaarioita, joita voi pelata rajattomasti uudelleen, jokaisen kuitenkin vain kerran per hahmo.

Uudelleenpelattavat skenaariot (4 xp):

• #1-01: The Absalom Initiation (Tier 1-4) by Lyz Liddell
• #1-06: Lost on the Spirit Road (Tier 1-4) by Christopher Wasko
• #1-10: Tarnbreaker's Trail (Tier 1-4) by Steven Hammond
• #1-14: Lions of Katapesh (Tier 1-4) by Adam Meyers
• #1-23: The Star-Crossed Court (Tier 3-6) by Alex Riggs
• #2-06 The Crashing Wave (Tier 3-6) by Dustin Knight
• #2-11: The Pathfinder Trials (Tier 1) by Sean McGowan
• Intro #1: The Second Confirmation (Tier 1-2) by Thurston Hillman
• Intro #2: United in Purpose (Tier 1-2) by Brian Duckwitz
• #3-01: Intro: Year of Shattered Sanctuaries (Tier 1-4) by Mike Kimmel
• #3-13: Guardian's Covenant (Tier 3-6) by Christopher Wasko Ilmestyy huhtikuu/2022

Uudelleenpelattavat questit & bountyt (1 xp):

• Quest #1A: The Sandstone Secret (Tier 1-4) by Linda Zayas-Palmer
• Quest #4: Port Peril Pub Crawl (Tier 1-4) by James Case
• Quest #9: Wayfinder Origins (Tier 3-6) by Dustin Knight
• Bounty #1: The Whitefang Wyrm (Tier 1) by Michael Sayre
• Bounty #2: Blood of the Beautiful (Tier 1) by Thurston Hillman
• Bounty #3: Shadows and Scarecrows (Tier 1) by Thurston Hillman
• Bounty #4: Cat's Cradle (Tier 1) by Hilary Moon Murphy

Uudelleenpelattavat spesiaalit:

• #2-00: Special: The King in Thorns (Tier 1-8) by Kate Baker and Dennis Muldoon
  (Pelattavissa kerran jokaisella alatierillä 1-2, 3-6 & 7-8)
• #3-99: Special: Fate in the Future (Tier 1-8) by Jessica Catalan
  (Pelattavissa kerran jokaisella alatierillä 1-4 & 5-8)